Thinking Outside the Sandbox
AI visibility investment is growing and trust is a more powerful driver of growth.
by Beth Crain, founder of Spotted Pony PR

- Your organization is already being described in search, reviews, and by AI. Those AI answers vary from run to run, and they can get a brand wrong.
- Trust is now the second most powerful driver of profit, market share, and acquisition, behind only product or service quality, according to a 2025 Financial Times and IPA study of senior B2B decision-makers.
- Consistency, clarity, and credibility are the three signals that help a brand build and keep trust.
- The SPOTTED Brand Trust System shows what AI is saying about your organization, finds where it got it wrong, and helps you keep your brand consistent, clear, and credible wherever it is experienced.
I am not opposed to AI visibility as a strategy. I am, however, not convinced it’s the right strategy to spend so much effort and resources on. The evidence isn’t there yet. There are also too many variables that are out of our control.
A lot of brands are asking how to get named in AI. Fewer are asking whether what it says is true, and whether anyone believes it. It all has me wondering if we are even asking the right questions. AI is one of the biggest technological advances the world has seen. Is it enough to approach this time with the same thinking and strategies we used for ranking on Google? Or is it time we start thinking outside the sandbox?
OK, let’s talk about AI visibility
There is little data yet on the benefits of investing in AI visibility. It is too early to say. Still, there are some already beginning to question the return on AI visibility. One thing is certain. Your organization is being described in search, reviews, and by AI. Do you know what is being said? Is it true? Have you started doing regular brand audits?
The research on how AI chooses what to say is early, but it points the same way. AI answers vary a lot from one run to the next. In SparkToro's late-2025 study, ChatGPT and Google AI almost never gave the same list of brands twice in 100 runs. That makes the things you can control matter more.
If the internet is a library, AI is the librarian that now recommends and describes your brand, or not. It can also get it wrong. Just Google cases when AI has hallucinated brands. There are plenty of examples to keep you up at night. It’s important to be aware of the very real financial and reputational risk of being misrepresented.
Studies of AI accuracy have mostly measured news, not company descriptions. The Tow Center at Columbia tested eight AI search tools on 1,600 news queries. Together they gave incorrect answers to more than 60 percent.
Trust as a growth driver
Being named by AI is not the same as being believed.
In 2025 the Financial Times and the IPA surveyed more than 750 senior B2B decision-makers. Trust is now the second most powerful driver of outcomes like profit, market share, and acquisition, behind only the quality of the product or service. Twenty years ago it ranked sixth. More than two-thirds said trust in business has become more important. Only 22 percent of companies treat it as a board-level measure.
The same research found only 9 percent of those decision-makers say they trust generative AI. So when AI describes your organization, it is often describing you to people who are skeptical of it. That is why I start with trust, and not with visibility. Trust is built from the signals your brand sends, in every place someone meets it, and AI reads the same signals.
Trust signals for structural consistency
The SPOTTED Brand Trust System (SPOTTED) is not an AI visibility tool and was not designed for AI. I originally created the SPOTTED framework to focus on brand trust no matter where a brand is experienced. It exists to give organizations a tool for creating structural consistency for developing lasting trust. And, no, your brand guidelines are not enough, even if they were always enforced and followed throughout your organization.
SPOTTED forms a foundation you can build on with creativity, authenticity, and ingenuity without worrying if your brand is still intact. I focused on three main trust signals to build it - consistency, clarity, and credibility.
- Consistency. Say the same thing everywhere, so people and AI get the same story. McKinsey's 2026 Global B2B Pulse surveyed nearly 4,000 decision-makers in 13 countries. The top reason buyers gave for switching suppliers was inconsistent information across teams.
- Clarity. Make it easy to tell what you do and who you do it for. In one analysis of ChatGPT citations, the passages that got cited were nearly twice as likely to include a clear definition, and 44 percent of citations came from the first third of a page.
- Credibility. Proof. Credibility is the written, recorded, and reviewed evidence that backs up your claims that you can be trusted. It is your brand fulfilling a promise. In BrightLocal's 2026 survey, 97 percent of consumers read reviews for local business, and 41 percent always do, up from 29 percent the year before.
These signals weave through the seven dimensions of brand trust. Seen. Perceived. Obvious. Trusted. Talked About. Embedded. Differentiated. They reduce confusion, establish authority, and affirm reliability. They help you optimize your brand before the algorithm or technology to better secure your investments in AI visibility, ads, and beyond.
SPOTTED is positioned to not only see what AI is saying about you, but find where the AI got it wrong, in addition to helping you make sure your brand is consistent, clear, and credible wherever people and AI experience it so you can continue to build trust.
Getting named in AI is one question. Whether what it says is true, and whether anyone believes it, is the one that decides what happens next. Google taught us to think in rankings. AI is teaching us to think differently or risk being thrown out with the AI slop.
SPOTTED for organizations of all shapes and sizes launches this week. The first 50 founding members get a complete diagnostic, blueprint with action plan, and follow-up diagnostic for free, then receive 30% off for as long as they stay continuously subscribed. Visit www.spottedbrand.com to learn more and subscribe.
Head up. Heels down.
Beth

