Seeing is Not Believing
Being found is not trusted and chosen.
by Beth Crain, founder of Spotted Pony PR

“How do we reach more people for the holidays?” It sounds like a visibility problem, but it usually isn’t.
- Reach gets you found. What happens next depends on what people find.
- Trust is now as important in the buying decision as quality and value.
- People already have promotion fatigue and distrust holiday deals.
- Consistency, clarity and credibility build trust that is echoed by word of mouth, AI and reviews.
- Do you know if your audience believes you?
I recently spent too much time on Reddit. There’s plenty I could unpack about my time down the Reddit hole, like how easy it is to get banned by their automated system. Instead, I’ll focus on the theme I saw over and over in the business communities. Reach. While their initial questions asked about how to be found, the question beneath the surface was how to get more paying clients and customers.
As the holiday consumer experience ramps up, more organizations want more people to see their content, visit their storefronts and buy their goods and services. You can tell everyone how amazing your brand is in 100,000 videos and they are still more likely to go somewhere else where it feels like home and less like an assault by marketing. Trust is now as important in the buying decision as quality and value.1 So, what can organizations do to turn their reach into trust and be chosen?
All the noise, Noise, NOISE
This is a competitive time of year. I still have vivid memories of people fighting over Tickle Me Elmo in the local big-box store. It’s even more competitive for organizations trying to take full advantage of this festive, gift-giving season. It can feel impossible to rise above all the noise.
Holiday ads already fill the airwaves, mailboxes and social feeds. They have even taken over beloved stories like The Muppet Christmas Carol. I’m still undecided how I feel about my favorite holiday movie being turned into a Walmart ad.
Shoppers already have promotion fatigue. They don’t even trust the discounts. Boston Consulting Group’s annual Black Friday Consumer Study2 found “only 54% of consumers trust that advertised Black Friday prices are genuinely lower than usual, and one in five actively distrust them.” The same study2 scored what earns trust in a holiday deal (net scores).
- Retailer reputation and money-back guarantees, both 65%.
- Verified purchase reviews 59% and clear price comparisons 58%.
- Scarcity messages 8%, AI-written review summaries 4% and influencer recommendations 3%.
Reputation. Credibility. Clarity. Trust. All are more important to shoppers this season. All are important to your audience throughout the year. And they are increasingly important for your brand.
The gift that keeps giving
Consistency, clarity and credibility build trust. Weave them throughout the customer journey and they are echoed by word of mouth, AI answers and reviews.

Consider doing something different leading up to the holidays.
- Show, don’t tell. Magic is made from how you make people feel.
- Focus on connection. In person or online.
- Stand out. Give your audience a reason to know you, not just during the holidays.
- Be present. Do a joint event or campaign with a partner in your community. Keep nurturing those relationships all year.
- Start planning for next year. Put a reminder on your calendar for July or August to start planning for the next holiday season. Remember, trust takes time.
- Build trust all year. Not sure where to start? Take the free SPOTTED brand trust assessment.
Reach gets you found. It puts you in the room. What happens next depends on what people find when they get there. The reviews. The replies. The way you show up.
The holidays don't change that. They turn up the volume. More people are looking, and more people are checking. Some even check twice.
Before spending more to get louder this season, ask different questions. When people find us, will they believe us? Why should they trust us? Why should they choose us?
Last, but certainly not least, mark your calendars. Small Business Saturday is November 28, 2026. Support local and experience the magic of the holidays in your community.
Head up. Heels down.
Beth
P.S. BCG’s study2 also found that 78% of the consumers using AI for their holiday search say it increases their likelihood of buying. Do you know what AI and the world are saying about your brand? The SPOTTED Brand Trust System helps you audit what the world sees, what’s working, what’s not and what to do about it.
For more on trust signals, read my previous Narrative & Numbers article, Thinking Outside the Sandbox.
Sources
- Edelman Trust Institute. (2026). 2026 Edelman Trust Barometer Special Report: Brand Growth in an Insular World. Top 10 Findings (PDF)
- Boston Consulting Group. (2026, November 4). BCG’s annual Black Friday survey finds 1 in 5 consumers actively distrust advertised discounts. Press release

